Utah Supreme Court Justice Diana Hagen Responds to Misconduct Investigation

Utah Supreme Court Justice Diana Hagen Responds to Misconduct Investigation

Salt Lake City, Utah — A controversy has emerged around Diana Hagen, as state leaders move forward with an independent investigation into alleged judicial misconduct.

What Are the Allegations?

The investigation centers on claims that Justice Hagen had an inappropriate relationship with an attorney who argued cases before the Utah Supreme Court. The allegations originated from a complaint filed by another lawyer, based on statements from Hagen’s ex-husband.

The attorney involved, David Reymann, has denied the claims, calling them false.

Previous Review Already Closed

The Utah Judicial Conduct Commission had already reviewed the complaint and dismissed it due to insufficient evidence, closing the case earlier.

However, Utah’s top political leaders—including the governor and legislative heads—said the initial review left “important questions unresolved,” prompting a new independent probe.

Hagen’s Response

Justice Hagen has strongly denied any wrongdoing, stating she never acted under a conflict of interest and remains committed to judicial integrity.

She also emphasized that she took appropriate steps, including reporting the matter herself and recusing from relevant cases when necessary.

Supreme Court’s Statement

The Utah Supreme Court criticized the release of confidential complaint materials, saying the allegations had already been properly reviewed and dismissed under constitutional procedures.

Political and Public Reactions

• Lawmakers from both parties have called for a transparent and thorough investigation.
• Some officials warned that, if proven true, the allegations could undermine public trust in the judiciary.
  

  Judicial Integrity

  The controversy is tied to a major redistricting case that reshaped Utah’s congressional map, making the situation more politically sensitive.